TOP STORY: State Warns Old Lyme to Get Moving on Sewer Project

Old Lyme Water Pollution Control Authority Chairman Steve Cinami has spent much of the summer addressing concerns from town officials and the public about a plan to bring sewers to the shoreline in order to garner support for a fall referendum.

OLD LYME–With town officials and residents of Sound View Beach still clamoring for answers about the latest developments in a longstanding push to bring sewers to the Old Lyme shoreline, the state has warned Old Lyme First Selectwoman Martha Shoemaker that time is running out.

Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protecton (CT DEEP) Deputy Commissioner of Environmental Quality Emma Cimino in an Aug. 15 email warned Shoemaker that state and federal funding amounting to roughly half of the project cost is in jeopardy if the town doesn’t move forward with a townwide referendum authorizing the funding necessary to award construction contracts by mid October.

Failing to complete “one or more of those milestones” by mid-October “will significantly impact” the town’s ability to pursue a Clean Water Fund grant for 25% of the total project cost and a forgivable loan for another 25%, according to Cimino. 

Sound View Beach, which is owned by the town, is responsible for up to $17.1 million of the $70 million proposal to require residents of three private beach associations and the town-owned Sound View community to install sewers. The state and federal funding would bring the Sound View contribution to $8.5 million.

The state going back to the early 1980s has pushed for an end to pollution emanating from local beach communities, leading to a 2018 consent order with Old Colony Beach, Old Lyme Shores, and Miami Beach that resulted in the current shared sewer plan. Sound View Beach, which is under town control, was added in 2019 after voters in a townwide referendum agreed to spend $9.5 million on the public portion of the project with the understanding that affected neighborhoods would fund it.

The town, which is participating voluntarily in the sewer plan at this point, is doing so under the threat of a consent order from the state like the one forcing the private beach associations to act. 

Sound View residents have long asked for more specific information about how much they will have to shell out as the municipal bond is repaid over 20 years. They’ve also questioned the data underlying the state’s contention that sewers are necessary to resolve the potential for pollution in the area.

The Board of Selectmen, waiting for answers to those questions, has declined to send to the Board of Finance a resolution that would trigger another town-wide referendum on whether to borrow an additional $7.6 million for Sound View’s portion of the project. The vote is necessary because rampant inflation has driven up the total cost of the project, though the promise of reimbursement from the state and federal government means Sound View ratepayers will actually be paying less than the amount authorized in the first referendum. 

Cimino told Shoemaker the agency was aware the Board of Selectmen had not yet voted on moving the increased bond authorization to referendum because they were waiting for the Old Lyme WPCA to share more information with selectmen and the public. 

“I want to emphasize the need for quick action at each stage to remain aligned with the association timelines,” Cimino said. 

The Old Lyme Water Pollution Control Authority on Tuesday held a contentious project presentation in front of a crowd of mostly Sound View residents. Meanwhile, costs continue to climb as bids last week came back unexpectedly high for the Miami Beach portion of the project, exacerbating selectmen’s concerns about the feasibility and affordability of the project.

Shoemaker on Wednesday in a phone conversation with LymeLine said the referendum would have to occur by Oct. 15 to meet the state’s demands. Logistical requirements involving planning and publicizing the referendum require a decision from both the Old Lyme Board of Selectmen and Board of Finance by Sept. 30, according to Shoemaker. 

The Board of Selectmen is slated to meet in a special meeting early next week, she said.

Overnight Fire Destroys Old Lyme Cottage

OLD LYME–An overnight fire destroyed a seasonal cottage on Brookside Avenue in the Old Colony Beach Association area of town.

Old Lyme Fire Marshal Dave Roberge said the call from a neighbor came in around 1:43 a.m. Wednesday. Crews from Old Lyme Fire Department and several nearby departments found the house fully ablaze. 

The house was unoccupied at the time, Roberge said. There were no injuries. The cause remains under investigation by the fire marshal. 

There wasn’t much left of the house by the time crews arrived so it didn’t take firefighters long to put out the fire, according to Roberge. He described it as a “total loss.” Crews remained on scene until about 5:30 a.m.

Assessor’s records show the one story, 1940 bungalow at 27 Brookside Ave. is owned by Patricia Capasso of Wethersfield. 

Roberge said there was thermal damage to two homes on one side of the house.

Departments from East Lyme, Lyme, Essex, Old Saybrook and Clinton also responded. 

Roberge asked anyone with photos or video of the fire to send them to him at firemarshal@oldlyme-ct.gov. The information can also be submitted by sending a direct message to the Old Lyme Fire Department’s Facebook page at facebook.com/oldlymefire.

Editor’s Note: This article was updated to clarify the date of the fire.

TOP STORY: Lyme-Old Lyme Schools Welcome Back Students, Spirits High Despite ‘Temporary Upheaval’ of Construction

Center School preschool teacher Kinny Newman promised her classroom—a work of progress as of Monday morning—would look “stunning” by the start of school on Wednesday.

OLD LYME–Preschool teacher Kinny Newman early this week sat at her desk in a Center School classroom preparing for the start of school on Wednesday.

Newman, surrounded by rows of signature fern plants, reviewed a class list with instructional assistants Jennifer Martin and Sakura Gemme. 

Six students on the roster were siblings of previous students, according to the teacher. 

“It makes it all really real when you read their names,” she said. “And then you get really excited about it.” 

Newman said the ongoing renovation project to update the Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) system in the building – as well as three other schools in the district – slowed down classroom preparations, but she predicted the latest crop of preschool students wouldn’t be bothered by the temporary upheaval. 

“They’re resilient. We’re resilient. We’ll figure it out,” she said. 

The staff members were working on a tighter timeframe than usual because the renovation project had closed the doors of Center School, Mile Creek and Lyme-Old Lyme Middle School for most of the summer. Operations at Lyme Consolidated School during the same timeframe were condensed as staff members relocated within the building. 

Ian Neviaser, Superintendent of Lyme-Old Lyme Schools, said on Monday that the contents of all the classrooms were emptied into the auditorium for summertime storage while crews abated the building’s original ceilings of hazardous components. 

The previous Friday was the first day teachers could get into their classrooms, he said. The crunch to prepare for Wednesday’s opening had teachers, assistants and cleaning crews working throughout the weekend. 

“Normally, our teachers come back early and set up their classrooms – and many of them come in long before they’re required to be here,” he said. “They didn’t have that option this summer.” 

In Newman’s classroom, spirits were high after all the hours put in over the weekend left the women in a good position to be ready on time. 

“We’re not quite finished yet,” Newman warned. “I have a whole reading tent coming from Amazon.”

The renovation project involves upgrades to the HVAC and security systems in the four buildings, plus an addition and an expanded parking area at Mile Creek School. Voters in late 2022 authorized spending up to $57.5 million on the project, though the district will save about $17 million due to grant funding and lower than expected interest rates.

Center School preschool instructional assistant Jennifer Martin on Monday helped prepare the classroom for the 2025-26 school year.

The most noticeable changes to the schools will be seen in the front vestibules that welcome students on Wednesday, according to Neviaser. He said security changes made as a “retrofit” following the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting more than 10 years ago have been overhauled to align with state requirements for new construction. 

“These are more modern,” he said of the new doors and windows. “They are both blastproof and bulletproof, and allow us to monitor the comings and goings of visitors more easily due to increased visibility.”

With work at Center School, Lyme Consolidated and the middle school expected to be completed by the new year, he said the project at Mile Creek will extend for about a year and a half. 

Parents hoping for improved traffic flow due to the expansion will find themselves disappointed because the pickup and dropoff area is not slated to be reconfigured until next summer. 

“So this year the traffic flow is probably going to be about the same as it was in the past,” he said. 

He said the school added a preschool class at Lyme Consolidated after a new state law required students to be five-years-old by Sept. 1 to start kindergarten, resulting in fewer kindergarteners and more preschoolers. Officials condensed four kindergarten classrooms, which were evenly spread between Lyme Consolidated and Mile Creek, into three while moving a Lyme Consolidated kindergarten teacher to the preschool level. Preschool classrooms are traditionally in Center School. 

Neviaser this month emphasized at a Region 18 Board of Education meeting that Lyme Consolidated will house a preschool class for one year only because the shift promises to reverse itself when this year’s four-year-old cohort enters kindergarten next year. 

“So that’s new and unique,” the superintendent said from the school Monday as he prepared for the new school year. “And then we will be living through construction for a few more months.”

Fire Marshal Dave Roberge, in an email to Neviaser shared with the Region 18 PreK-8 Building Committee, acknowledged construction is ongoing. Roberge said he found the buildings are in compliance with fire detection, notification and evacuation requirements, and he will continue to monitor the situation as construction continues.

Old Lyme Property Transactions, 8/26/25

8/12: 10 Mill Pond Road, Susanne M. Stutts of Monroe to Kaitlyn Czap and Justin Czap, $1,000,000.

8/13: 146 Four Mile River Road, Lawrence R. Huck and Sally A. Huck to Michael McDermott, $505,000.

8/14: Buttonball Road, Lot 5, Reagan Homes LLC of Mystic to Kenneth Donovan of Stonington, $250,000.

8/15: 15-1 Tisbury Road, Victoria C. Haskins of Beaufort, SC, to Jonathan Starbranch, $615,000.

8/15: 5 Clarks Lane, Thomas S. Childs Revocable Trust of Vero Beach, FL, to Savannah Jane Veth, $1,050,000.

8/20: 7 Champion Road, William F. Griffin Jr., Trustee, of Boca Raton, FL, to Judith Muirhead, Trustee, of Avon, $850,000.

TOP STORY-UPDATED: U.S. News & World Report Ranks Lyme-Old Lyme High School 8th in State, Breaking Top 500 Nationally

The entrance to Lyme-Old Lyme High School. LymeLine file photo.

OLD LYME—Lyme-Old Lyme High School (LOLHS) is among the Top 10 high schools in Connecticut and the Top 500 in the nation, according to U.S. News & World Report

The school earned eighth place on the Best High Schools list released this week. The rankings are compiled annually based on state-required test scores, graduation rates and how well each school prepares students for college.

Lyme-Old Lyme High School ranked 415 out of nearly 18,000 public high schools across the country. 

Superintendent of Lyme-Old Lyme Schools Ian Neviaser on Friday welcomed the news.

“This recognition reflects the hard work and dedication of our students, the expertise and commitment of our teachers and staff, and the strong support of our families and community,” he said.

Neviaser added, “We will continue to challenge ourselves to provide an exceptional education for every student while preparing them for success in college, careers, and life beyond Lyme-Old Lyme.”

The Top 10 Best High Schools in Connecticut identified by U.S. News & World Report are: 

  • 1. Connecticut IB Academy, East Hartford
  • 2. New Canaan High School
  • 3. Weston High School
  • 4. Darien High School
  • 5. Wilton High School
  • 6. Staples High School, Westport
  • 7. Marine Science Magnet High School of Southeastern Connecticut, Groton 
  • 8. Lyme-Old Lyme High School
  • 9. Greenwich High School
  • 10. Hall High School, West Hartford

Lyme-Old Lyme High School and Marine Science Magnet High School are the only schools in New London County to break the Top 10. 

Here’s how other local area schools stacked up: 

  • 17. East Lyme High School
  • 20. Stonington High School
  • 31. Haddam-Killingworth High School
  • 45. Wheeler High School, N. Stonington
  • 49. Valley Regional High School, Deep River
  • 50. Westbrook High School
  • 51. Waterford High School
  • 52. Old Saybrook High School
  • 54. The Morgan School, Clinton
  • 68. Bacon Academy, Colchester
  • 76. Robert E. Fitch High School, Groton
  • 77. Montville High School
  • 88. Ledyard High School
  • 91. Science and Technology Magnet Pathway for High School Grades, New London
  • 102. Lyman Memorial High School, Lebanon
  • 105. Griswold High School
  • 115. Nathan Hale-Ray High School, East Haddam
  • 135. Norwich Free Academy
  • 144. Three Rivers Middle College Magnet School, Norwich
  • 154. Norwich Technical High School
  • 158. Ella T. Grasso Southeastern Technical High School, Groton 
  • 160. New London High School
  • 171. New London Visual and Performing Arts Magnet School

The 2025 rankings are based on three-year old data described by US News & World Report in a press release as the most recent state and federal figures available.  

Data shows 67% of Lyme-Old Lyme’s 392 students at the time took at least one Advanced Placement (AP) exam, with 62% passing. The graduation rate was 98%. 

The media company said schools are evaluated on how effectively they serve all students, including underserved populations, with college readiness measured through student participation and performance on AP and International Baccalaureate exams.

Seventeen percent of LOLHS students at the time identified as Black, Hispanic, Asian or biracial, according to the report. About 14% of students were considered economically disadvantaged.

Lyme-Old Lyme High School ranked 13th in the 2024 rankings and 34th the year prior. 

Editor’s Note: This article was updated with a quote from Superintendent Neviaser.