UPDATED: Early Voters In CT Top 170,000, With Just Over 2,000 from Lyme and Old Lyme

Lyme Republican Registrar of Voters Judith Davies (right) and Democratic Moderator Mary Stone work an 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. schedule on Tuesday, Oct. 28.

Editor’s Note: This story was first published on Nov. 3 as a Staff Report by CT News Junkie, and is republished here with their permission. The Lyme and Old Lyme data has been added by Elizabeth Regan.

Before polls opened this morning for Election Day, more than 170,000 Connecticut residents had already cast a ballot.

That includes 1,553 early voters in Old Lyme and 530 in Lyme, according to local voting officials.

Data from Secretary of the State Stephanie Thomas’ office shows voters also returned more than 20,000 absentee ballots, which will be counted today. 

In Old Lyme, Deputy Registrar of Voters Katherine Thuma said turnout over the 14-day early voting period consisted of 675 Democrats, 461 unaffiliated voters, 402 Republicans and 15 minor party voters. That’s compared to total registered voters as of Tuesday that totaled 2,546 unaffiliated voters, 1,963 Democrats, 1,644 Republicans and 97 minor party voters.

By mid-day Tuesday, Thuma said 155 absentee ballots had been processed.

Lyme Registrar of Voters Judith Davies and Dottie Wells said early voting brought in 253 Democrats, 165 unaffiliated voters, 103 Republicans and 9 minor party voters. While a breakdown of the affiliations of all registered voters wasn’t immediately available on Tuesday, data from Thomas’ office as of Oct. 17 shows there were 734 unaffiliated voters, 717 Democrats, 444 Republicans and 31 minor party voters.

Wells said 31 absentee ballots had been received as of Monday.

Of the 170,920 early voters to cast a ballot as of Nov. 2, 83,479 are registered Democrats, and 36,525 are Republicans. Another 48,830 are not affiliated with either party and 2,085 are classified as “other,” Thomas’ office said.

Of the 20,197 absentee ballots, Democrats returned 10,277 and Republicans 4,402 with 5,299 unaffiliated and 219 others.

These totals are audited throughout the early voting period, according to Thomas’ office.

Stratford, driven by a contentious mayor’s race, continues to lead the way with 4,743 early voters, followed by Milford with 4,414, Greenwich with 3,706 and Hamden with 3,679. Trumbull (3,616) rounded out the top 5. The rest of the 10 top early voting communities were Norwalk (3,481), Fairfield (3,410), West Hartford (3,057), Stamford (2,771), and Bristol (2,744).

Last year, in a presidential election year, nearly 750,000 voters took advantage of early voting to cast a ballot. That represented just under a third of Connecticut’s 2.3 million registered voters.

Editor’s Note: This article was updated with early voting and voter registration totals from Old Lyme voting officials and again with additional Lyme numbers.

Still Deciding? Here Are All Our Lyme/Old Lyme-Related Election Articles, Candidate Q & A’s, and Letters to Help

Incumbent First Selectwoman Martha Shoemaker (left to right) is running against Republican John Mesham in Old Lyme, while Republican Tom St. Louis challenges unaffiliated, Democrat-backed candidate Christy Zelek in Lyme.

LYME/OLD LYME–Still making up your mind how to cat your vote? We’ve compiled all our election coverage in one place to help you make an informed decision.

If you haven’t already voted, don’t forget to cast that ballot before the clock runs out. Get the details here

Read on to explore the candidates and issues through our original reporting, the candidates’ own voices, and perspectives from neighbors across Lyme and Old Lyme.

Election Reporting

Rare First Selectman Contest in Lyme Pits Corporate Experience Against Volunteer Approach

Focus on Kids and Community—Not Politics—Dominates Region 18 Candidates’ Friendly Forum

Shoemaker, Mesham Back for Another First Selectman Run in Old Lyme

Failed Halls Road Overlay Makes Way for Election Day in Old Lyme

With Democrats Absent, Republican Couple Takes Center Stage at Lyme Candidate Forum

‘It Matters That You Vote’: Lyme Residents Turn Out Early for Familiar Election Day Ritual

Old Lyme Democrats Announce First Selectwoman Martha Shoemaker’s Bid for Reelection

Old Lyme Republicans Announce Nomination of John Mesham in Rematch for First Selectman

Lyme Republicans Endorse Tom St. Louis for First Selectman

Lyme Democrats Support Unaffiliated Petitioning Candidate Christy Zelek for First Selectman

Candidate Q&A Series 

Old Lyme Board of Selectmen Candidates Respond to Our Questions

Lyme Board of Selectpeople Candidates Respond to Our Questions

Region 18 Board of Education Candidates Respond to Our Questions

Old Lyme Zoning Commission Candidates Respond to Our Questions

Letters to the Editor

William J. Belluzzi: Fogliano Will Use Analytic, Research Skills Gained as Career Scientist to Benefit Old Lyme Zoning Commission

Tom Beyer: LymeLine Editor Criticized for Publishing Gencarella Letter Accusing Zelek of Plagiarism

Alice Burbank: Response by Then-Selectwoman Shoemaker Leads to Support for her Current First Selectman Challenger

Bud Canaday: Don’t Reelect HROD Advocates Shoemaker, Lampos; Vote Row B

Joe Carpentino: Fogliano is ‘Fair-minded, Collaborative and Knowledgeable’ Zoning Candidate

Danielle Chesebrough: Looking for Steady Leadership for Old Lyme’s Future? Behringer Deserves Your Vote

Kevin Clougherty: Reader Questions Kelsey’s Position on Halls Road ‘Political Football’

Sarah Crisp: Checks and Balances are Important for Lyme

Mary Daley: Martha and Jim Roll Up Their Sleeves for the People

Suzanne Derry: Old Lyme is a Functioning Democracy, No Need for ‘Venom’ Being Injected Into Local Campaign Rhetoric

George Finley: Why Won’t Old Lyme Republicans Participate in a Debate?

Michael Fogliano: Fogliano, Candidate for Old Lyme Zoning Commission, Explains His Reasons for Running

Allan Dodds Frank: Lyme Deserves Better

Stephen Olbrys Gencarella: Plagiarism is No Way to Start a Campaign

Christina J and Thomas D Gotowka: Shoemaker/Lampos Supporters Say ‘If it Isn’t Broken, Don’t Fix It’

Rebecca Griffin: With Trump in Charge Nationally, Only Defense is to Limit Republican Role Locally, so Vote Democrat

Timothy Griswold: Former First Selectman Griswold Endorses Mesham, Read for Old Lyme Board of Selectmen

Betsy Groth: Danenhower Disrespected Due Process on Zoning Commission, Elect Alternate Fogliano to Full Term

Lucinda Hautaniemi: Behringer, Linderman, Walsh Support Fiscal Responsibility

Anna B. James and Gavin Lodge: Lyme School Board Rep’s Endorse Zelek as ‘Uniter’

John Kiker: Lyme Democrats Choose Conversation Over Confrontation

Jim Lampos: An Open Letter to the Citizens of Old Lyme from Selectman Lampos

Howard Margules: The Missing Word on Old Lyme Campaign Signs, and a Simple Question

Fred McCullough: Writer ‘Disheartened’ by Old Lyme Republican Postcard; Requests Civility, Absence of Divisiveness 

Carolyn Miranda: Shoemaker Keeps Her Promises

Mary Jo Nosal: Shoemaker, Lampos Have Achieved Much in Short Time, Deserve Re-election

Tom Ortoleva: Elect Fogliano to Old Lyme Zoning Commission to Benefit From His ‘Deep Knowledge … Open Mind’

Phyllis Ross: Contrary to RTC Mailer Statement, Lyme Affordable Housing Commission (AHC) Member Says AHC Does Not Believe in High-density Housing

Michael Reiter: Reiter Reminds Readers to Exercise Caution When Deciding Who to Vote for in November

David Rubino: Democracy is on the Ballot … Even Here in Old Lyme

Sandra Y. Rueb: Vote Kimberly Thompson for Responsible Fiscal Leadership in Old Lyme

Andy Russell: Veteran Old Lyme Board of Finance (BOF) Member Endorses ‘Capable … Deeply Committed’ Republican Slate of BOF Candidates

Martha Shoemaker: An Open Letter to the Residents of Old Lyme from First Selectwoman Shoemaker

Ed Shyloski: Old Lyme Republican Pledges Support for Democratic BOE Candidate Shyloski

Joseph G. Soucie: When Voting Nov. 4, Remember Old Lyme Board of Finance D’s, R’s Disagree Deeply on Town Surplus 

Steve Spooner: Endorsing J. David Kelsey—a ‘Generous Supporter of All Things Old Lyme’—for Board of Finance

Thomas St. Louis: Residents Deserve to Hear From Candidates in Open Forum

Leanne Viola: Attendance Records for Old Lyme Board of Finance Candidates Thompson, Kelsey Differ Sharply

Jonathan B. Wilder: If Political Campaign Banners are OK in Old Lyme, National Flags Should be OK Too

Op-Eds

Rick Drake: Tuesday, November 4th & the HROD

George Frampton Jr: The Not-Secret and Completely Transparent Facts About Tantummaheag Landing

Stephen Olbrys Gencarella: Why Plagiarism Matters in Our Local Election

Letter to the Editor: Attendance Records for Old Lyme Board of Finance Candidates Thompson, Kelsey Differ Sharply

To the Editor:

We live in a representative democracy and this November you are being charged with electing fellow Old Lyme residents to be your representatives on local boards and commissions. One of the most basic things you should expect from your representatives is that they show up, at least most of the time, so that they can understand the issues and represent your interests. We do have alternates for many of our boards who step in when a regular member is ill or has some other unavoidable conflict. However, there are issues that carry over multiple meetings and repeated absences can lead to representatives making decisions without having all important information.

This is extremely relevant in this year’s Board of Finance race. Kimberly Thompson, the Democratic candidate, has served on this board since November 2021. Since being sworn in to her seat, Kim has only missed one meeting. Since January 2024, one of her opponents, J. David Kelsey, has missed 12 meetings, constituting about 35% of the total.  Five of these missed meetings have been in 2025 and, as of this writing, David has not been seen at the Board of Finance since June. To earn your vote, members should show up for Old Lyme. Please join me in voting for Kimberly Thompson on November 4 for a full Board of Finance seat.

Sincerely,

Leanne Viola,
Old Lyme.

Letter to the Editor: Fogliano is ‘Fair-minded, Collaborative and Knowledgeable’ Zoning Candidate

To the Editor: 

Our small town of Old Lyme will be tackling several serious issues in the next few years, which will shape our future in ways important to all of us. It is because of this that I am putting my full support behind Michael Fogliano for election to the Zoning Commission. He is uniquely qualified to tackle these issues, evidenced by his experience in housing and zoning, planning, and technology. 

Michael is a seasoned leader shown to be reliable, logical and reasonable. He will use those tools to ensure our town is put in the best position to make the most informed decisions. He is fair-minded, collaborative and knowledgeable in local, state and federal regulations affecting zoning as well as the proposed changes to those regulations. Michael is the kind of person I want on our Zoning Commission, and the kind of person Old Lyme needs. He will put our town first and will reflect the values and traditions we have all come to appreciate. 

In all, Michael’s experience, his nature and personality have prepared him to engage in the challenges of shifting economics, demographics and public policy that we will inevitably confront. He is a team player with know-how, and the common sense to preserve the best of Old Lyme while advocating for the careful changes that will help us meet the future together.

Please join me in voting for Mike Fogliano for the Zoning Commission. 

Sincerely,

Joe Carpentino ,
Old Lyme.

TOP STORY: ‘It Matters That You Vote’: Lyme Residents Turn Out Early for Familiar Election Day Ritual

Democratic Registrar of Voters Dottie Wells checks in voters during early voting in Lyme Town Hall on Tuesday, Oct. 28.

LYME, CT—Resident Michael Tuccio was among a small surge of Wednesday afternoon voters, who came through the typically quiet voting area set up in Lyme Town Hall’s main meeting room since Oct. 20. 

By the time he got there, election officials said voters had cast 335 ballots as part of the two-week early voting period. Combined with 31 absentee ballots, that amounts to about 19% of the town’s 1,932 registered voters. 

Tuccio said casting a ballot through the early voting process, which was instituted last year to give voters two weeks to vote prior to Election Day, is not notably different from voting on Election Day. 

Last year’s presidential election saw 497 early votes in total, according to data from the Office of the Secretary of the State. 

“It’s just kind of normal,” he said, comparing this year to a lifetime of voting that he considers everyone’s civic duty. 

The continuity is important to Tuccio, who said his preference is for things to stay the same. That’s why he said he supports candidates, who will reject residential development in the face of state efforts to promote affordable housing. 

“I’m just staunchly opposed to change in general,” he said. 

That’s not to say there aren’t procedural differences when it comes to voting early. 

As part of the mid afternoon burst of activity, Tuccio and the other voters checked in with Democratic Registrar of Voters Dottie Wells to receive a ballot and an envelope. 

The line grew to include several people at times during the two o’clock hour. It was a change from the slower and more sporadic trickle that had dominated early voting for the prior eight days. 

“We’re getting a little rush here,” Wells said. “This is very exciting.” 

Each voter was directed to one of the privacy booths to fill out the ballot envelope, seal it and sign it before handing it to Republican Registrar of Voters Judith Davies to be scanned into the system. Voters were instructed to drop the envelopes in the holding box, where they would remain until being transported to the town clerk’s vault at the end of the day.

Republican Registrar of Voters Judith Davies (right) and Democratic Moderator Mary Stone await the next early voter in Lyme Town Hall.

Davies described “an elaborate process” for getting the ballots to the town clerk that includes both registrars to ensure the proper chain of custody. The ballots stay in the vault until Election Day, when they will be counted by poll workers from both parties in the same process used for absentee ballots. 

Davies, a 7-year registrar of voters, and Wells, who’s been in the role for 2.5 years, each work 12 of the 14-day early voting schedule. The days run from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. through Nov. 2, except for two elongated 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. shifts. One of those extended shifts was Wednesday; the next is Thursday. 

Davies said the three-person shifts include both registrars – or an assistant registrar if Wells or Davies have the day off – and one moderator.  Registrars make an hourly rate of $22, while moderators and poll workers make about $17. 

“It’s long hours, but we’re happy to be here because obviously voting is important,” she said. 

She credited a team of 15 poll workers, including four moderators, for making the job an enjoyable experience from early voting through Election Day. The team consists of experienced workers as well as new additions this year. 

Davies counted weekends as the slowest period, with 22 voters on Saturday and 16 on Sunday. She said poll workers sometimes read or knit during down time that can extend to an hour at times. 

Moderator Mary Stone is scheduled for six days of early voting. She said it’s been good to see the turnout from voters, who are grateful for the opportunity to vote early – and to more easily find a place to park at the Town Hall. 

“By and large, they’re overwhelmingly appreciative,” she said. “They appreciate avoiding the crowds on Election Day.”

For Tuccio, Wednesday afternoon was a convenient day to vote on his way home from work. He saw others, who found early voting convenient because the less hectic pace suits their age or level of mobility. 

He said the extended calendar enhances the experience for voters.

The U.S. Marine Corps veteran counted liberty as one of his guiding principles. 

It doesn’t matter who you vote for, according to Tuccio – “it matters that you vote.”