Letter to the Editor: Proposed Changes to Lyme-Old Lyme Schools Music Program Will Negatively Impact Students, Teacher, Program Itself

To the Editor:

I graduated from the Lyme-Old Lyme Class of 2021 and am now a Senior set to graduate from the Bryant University Honors Program in May of this year with a Marketing Major. I strongly urge the Lyme-Old Lyme Board of Education to reconsider the decisions that have been made about the music program. There are numerous ways that this change will negatively impact students, the teacher, and the program itself. 

Music isn’t just a class—it’s a place where students gain confidence, find their voice, and feel supported. While the program isn’t being cut, stretching one teacher between two schools will make it impossible to provide the same level of mentorship and musical excellence that students rely on. 

I know this firsthand because I was in Chorus from third grade through my senior year of high school. Now, as a member of an accomplished a cappella group at Bryant University, I would not be where I am today without Mrs. Pekar. She was the one who encouraged me to audition, who helped me develop the skills to succeed in music, and who inspired me every day to be the best I can be. Without her support, I would never have considered pursuing music at this level. 

For me, the music program was more than a class, and Mrs. Pekar was more than a teacher—she was my mentor and biggest supporter. During my senior year, I spent over 2000 hours with her. To put that into perspective, an average student spends just 216 hours a year with a teacher if they have them 4 times a week, since Lyme-Old Lyme recognizes the drop-period curriculum. Whether it was show choir, concert chorus, practicing piano for my senior project, or starring in the musical, which she has been brilliantly directing for 4 years now, she was and still is there for me and all students. 

But her impact on my life goes far beyond music. If not for her helping me build my confidence from the ground up, I wouldn’t have had the courage to compete in sales competitions in Chicago—where I advanced further than many of my peers. 

After dedicating so much time and energy to students, she now won’t even have a moment to catch her breath between classes. This change doesn’t just affect students—it affects the teacher, the program, and the heart of the school community. Please ensure that each school has the dedicated support it deserves. The impact of a great teacher lasts far beyond the classroom—I am living proof of that. 

Sincerely,

Sophia Ortoleva,
Old Lyme.

Old Lyme Puts Up Brave Fight in Div. V State Championship, But Shepaug Completes Perfect Season With 58-46 Win

Sophomore Eddie Fiske Jr. (#34) was the Wildcats top-scorer in their championship game against Shepaug Valley with 15 points. All photos by Warner Swain.

MOHEGAN SUN–Top-seeded Shepaug Valley completed their unbeaten season Saturday, capping it with victory in the CIAC Division V State Championship when they soundly defeated Old Lyme 58-46. This was a first-time state tournament win for Shepaug Valley.

Old Lyme coach Brady Sheffield gives instructions to his team during a time-out in the game against Shepaug Valley.

The Wildcats were defending champions having won the Division V title last year under then-21-year-old coach Brady Sheffield, who was in his first year as coach at that time.

Old Lyme Junior Colman Curtiss-Reardon contributed nine points to the Wildcats final score.

Sophomore Edward Fiske Jr. was Old Lyme’s top scorer with 15 points while junior Colman Curtiss-Reardon and freshman William McKeever notched nine each.

Old Lyme freshman Will McKeever notched nine points for the Wildcats, including two three-pointers.

Shepaug Valley’s Andrew Konik was the game’s top-scorer with 21 points and eight steals. Reed Woerner and James Kersten added 14 and 12 points respectively.

Old Lyme Junior Oliver Wyman played a determined game for the Wildcats.

Old Lyme Defeats Coginchaug 56-49 in State Tourney Quarter-Final! Meets Grasso Tech in Monday’s Semifinal

Old Lyme’s Eddie Fiske Jr. (#34) was top scorer in Tuesday’s game against Hartford Public. All photos by Warner Swain.

OLD LYME—Third-seeded Lyme-Old Lyme boys tip off against #6 seeds Coginchaug tonight at 6:30 p.m. in the Lyme-Old Lyme High School gym.

No regular season admission passes will be accepted as this is a CIAC event.

All tickets must be purchased through GoFan at the following link: GoFan Ticket Purchase. No cash will be accepted at the door. 

The game will be televised live on the NFHS Network—a fee will be charged to watch the game.

Go Wildcats!

Old Lyme’s Gilbert Wins Mile at New England Championship with Record-Breaking Time

Lyme-Old Lyme High School junior Chase Gilbert stands atop the medal podium after her record-breaking first place win in the New England Championship mile. Photos by A. Mercaldi.

Old Lyme’s Eastman-Grossel Comes Fifth in 300m Setting Both LOLHS Record, Personal Best

BOSTON, MAUPDATED 1:30pm with coach’s comments: At yesterday’s New England Indoor Track and Field Championship held at the Reggie Lewis Track and Athletic Center in Boston, Mass., Old Lyme’s Chase Gilbert took first place in the mile with a time of 4:48.45, setting not only a meet record, but also a Lyme-Old Lyme High School (LOLHS) record and a personal best.

Chase Gilbert celebrates her victory in the mile at the New England Championships.

Old Lyme senior Zoe Eastman-Grossel came in fifth in the 300 meters with a time of 40.14, setting both a LOLHS record and a personal best.

After her graduation from LOLHS in June this year, Eastman-Grossel has committed to run D1 Track and Field at the Naval Academy in Annapolis, Md.

Zoe Eastman-Grossel displays her medal after coming in fifth in the 300 meters at the New England Championships with both a school record and a personal best time.

Asked how she felt about these remarkable achievements, LOLHS Track & Field Coach Alyssa Mercaldi told LymeLine exclusively, ” We are incredibly proud of Chase and Zoe.”

She continued, “After both battling injuries last indoor season, their resilience and determination to come back stronger have been truly inspiring.

Mercaldi concluded, “Seeing their hard work payoff is a testament to their dedication and perseverance.”

Editor’s Note: Congratulations from all of us at LymeLine to these exceptional athletes on their record-breaking results!

Old Lyme Basketball Boys are Shoreline Champions!

Sweet victory! The Lyme-Old Lyme Wildcats celebrate their 59-55 win over East Hampton in the Shoreline Championship. All photos by Warner Swain except where indicated.

MADISON, CT—On Tuesday evening, Feb. 25, the Lyme-Old Lyme boys’ basketball team won the Shoreline Championship defeating East Hampton 59-55.

Old Lyme sophomore Eddie Fiske, Jr. (#34) scored a game-high 24 points for the Wildcats.

Sophomore Eddie Fiske scored a game-high 24 points for the Wildcats while junior Colman Curtiss-Reardon added 17—Oliver Wyman notched 11 points for Old Lyme.

Old Lyme junior Colman Curtiss-Reardon advances down the court in Tuesday’s Shoreline Championship game against East Hampton. He netted 17 points in the game.

Brady Lynch was top scorer for the Bellringers with 17 points with Austin Cuthbertsin adding 12—Bryson Milton scored 10 points.

Old Lyme’s Brady Sheffield was named Shoreline Conference “Coach of the Year” before the game began.

Old Lyme, who are the reigning state champions, will compete next in the CIAC Division V State Tournament entering as the #3 seed. Their opponent, the date, and location of their first game is yet to be announced.

Old Lyme’s Eddie Fiske, Jr., at far right, was named Shoreline Conference “Player of the Year” and awarded 1st Team All Conference.

Prior to the start of the game, this season’s Shoreline All-Conference selections were announced. Lyme-Old Lyme honors were as follows:

  • Brady Sheffield – Shoreline Conference “Coach of the Year”
  • Eddie Fiske Jr. – Shoreline Conference “Player of the Year” and “1st Team All Conference”.
  • Colman Curtiss-Reardon – Second Team All Conference
  • Ryan Hill – All Conference Honorable Mention
Shoreline champions! The Old Lyme Wildcats proudly celebrate their 59-55 victory over East Hampton. Photo by A. Hine.

CONGRATULATIONS, WILDCATS!